All articles

Prices loaded . Sale and estimate dates are shown with each value.

Trading Card Deal Alerts Based on Sold Prices (2026): 12 Real Snipes, With Receipts
October 15, 202619 min readBy CardboardSniper Research

Trading Card Deal Alerts Based on Sold Prices (2026): 12 Real Snipes, With Receipts

On this page
  1. 01What a sold-price alert is
  2. 02Twelve real snipes
  3. 03The 1990 Fleer Jordan pair
  4. 04Vintage Pokemon
  5. 05The listing the seller pulled
  6. 06Alert to gone
  7. 07Auctions are not deals yet
  8. 08Why grade matched
  9. 09Read an alert in 30 seconds
  10. 1077 days of alerts
  11. 11Set up the alert
  12. 12FAQ

A trading card deal alert based on sold prices compares every new listing against recorded sales of the same card, at the same grade, from the same grader, and tells you within minutes when a listing is priced below that number. It is a different animal from a keyword alert, which fires on every match, and from a price alert, which fires on a ceiling you typed in last month. This page shows twelve real alerts the CardboardSniper scanner fired between July 25 and September 22, 2026, with receipts: the listing price, the grade-matched comp at the moment of the alert, the recorded sales behind that comp, and what happened to the card afterward, checked on eBay. Read it next to how grade-matched comps work and the card sniping playbook.

Verified receipts
12
8 Buy It Now, 4 auctions, Jul 25 to Sep 22
Fastest sale
2 min
2003 Topps Chrome LeBron #111 PSA 9 at 21% below
Catches in 77 days
2,642
listings 8 to 60% below a full grade-matched comp
Median gap
34%
median listing price $499; 935 catches over $1,000

What a Sold-Price Deal Alert Actually Is

Most card alerts tell you a listing exists. A sold-price alert tells you whether it is cheap. An eBay saved search emails you at most once per day, and only when new listings match in the prior 24 hours; it cannot tell a steal from a listing at double the going rate. A price alert is one step better, but the number you typed in goes stale the first time the market moves. A sold-price alert already knows what the card last sold for at that exact grade, so each new listing is judged against a number the market set, not one you set.

Two details decide whether this kind of alert is worth anything. The comp has to be grade matched, meaning a PSA 9 is judged against PSA 9 sales and never against the PSA 10 price. And the alert has to arrive while the listing is still buyable, which for an underpriced Buy It Now listing is measured in minutes, not days. CardboardSniper's comp is the average of the last three sane recorded sales of the exact card and grade, with obvious outliers trimmed; when a grade has no recent sales the alert shows no verdict rather than borrowing a number from another grade. The email looks like this:

Listed, alerted, sold: the 2003 Topps Chrome LeBron James #111 PSA 9 listed at $4,000 against a $5,038 sold comp, 21 percent below, sold two minutes after the alert
Listed, alerted, sold in two minutes. The first receipt below, in one frame: a real listing, a real grade-matched comp, and the gap the alert carried.

Twelve Real Snipes, With Receipts

Start with the eight Buy It Now catches, because those are the ones where minutes matter. For each one the table shows the price it listed at, the grade-matched comp at the moment the alert fired, and what the listing did next. Outcomes come from the eBay listing pages themselves, re-checked in October. The first six were bought; the last two were pulled by the seller before anyone bought them.

Eight Buy It Now alerts, July 25 to September 22, 2026. Listed price and comp are the alert's own numbers; the outcome is what eBay shows for the listing today. Card links open the live sales history.
CardAlertListed atSold compGapWhat happened
2003 Topps Chrome LeBron James #111 PSA 9Aug 7$4,000$5,03821%Sold 2 minutes after the alert
1990 Fleer Michael Jordan #26 PSA 9Jul 27$59.99$9235%Gone in 28 minutes
1990 Fleer Michael Jordan #26 PSA 10Jul 27$749.99$8178%Gone in 11 hours
1990 Fleer Michael Jordan #26 PSA 10Jul 25$739$81710%Gone in 19 hours
1999 Fossil Zapdos Holo 1st Edition PSA 9Sep 14$550$89739%Sold in 19 hours
2002 Expedition Kingler Holo PSA 9Sep 22$497.55$89344%Sold in 5 days
2003 Topps LeBron James #221 PSA 10Aug 22$4,550$7,66641%Seller ended it after 40 hours, citing a listing error
2003 Topps LeBron James #221 PSA 10Sep 22$5,600$7,66627%Seller ended it after 62 hours, same reason

The fastest one is the clearest case. On August 7 at 4:13 UTC a seller with a few thousand feedback listed a 2003 Topps Chrome LeBron James #111 PSA 9 at $4,000. Eight PSA 9 sales were on record from the prior three weeks, from $4,400 to $6,000; the alert priced it at $5,038 and called it 21 percent below. eBay's own page shows the sale time: 9:15 PM Pacific, two minutes after the alert.

eBay listing page for the 2003 Topps Chrome LeBron James #111 PSA 9 showing the banner This listing sold on Thu, Aug 6 at 9:15 PM and the price US $4,000.00
eBay's receipt for the LeBron Chrome PSA 9: sold at $4,000 on August 6 at 9:15 PM Pacific, two minutes after the scanner flagged it.

A note on the spotlights that follow. Each one charts the recorded sales the pricing engine holds for that exact card and grade, and the footer states the date of the newest sale in the chart. The comp in each alert was computed from those sales on the day the alert fired, so the chart is the evidence behind the number, not today's price. The live card page behind every spotlight link carries the current data.

2003 Topps Chrome LeBron James #111PSA 10
2003 Topps Chrome LeBron James #111

Sale-based value

$12,000.00

Price evidence dated 2026-11-16

Verified sales · 58 observations2026-11-16 · $9,000.00
Verified sales, 2026-09-05 to 2026-11-16. Range $9,000.00 to $20,000.00.$21,320.00$16,773.00$12,227.00$7,680.002026-09-052026-11-16
Latest recorded sales
2003 Topps Chrome LeBron James #111, PSA 10 recorded sales
DateVenueSold for
2026-11-16Fanatics Collect$9,000.00
2026-11-16Fanatics Collect$9,000.00
2026-11-15eBay$11,725.00
2026-11-15eBay$11,100.00
2026-11-12Alt$10,994.40
Price check: 2026-11-16. A price check does not mean a new sale occurred.Full card details →

The chart in the spotlight is the PSA 9 sales history for this card through August 5, straight from the pricing engine. Trace the summer and the $4,000 listing sits under every sale from late July and early August. Whoever bought it did not need to open a single sold listing, because the comp was already in the alert. That is the entire point of pricing against sold data instead of a number you typed in.

Small Gaps Clear Fast: The 1990 Fleer Jordan Pair

Two 1990 Fleer Michael Jordan #26 PSA 10s listed 8 and 10 percent under the $817 comp in the same week, and both were gone within a day. Fourteen PSA 10 sales were on record for July, from $660 to $825, with most of them between $750 and $810. A $749.99 Buy It Now is not a flip, it is a collector discount, and on a card with this much liquidity a collector discount clears in hours because dozens of people want the card at the comp. The $739 copy on July 25 lasted 19 hours; the $749.99 copy on July 27 lasted 11.

1990 Fleer Michael Jordan #26PSA 10
1990 Fleer Michael Jordan #26

Sale-based value

$650.00

Price evidence dated 2026-11-16

Verified sales · 66 observations2026-11-16 · $635.00
Verified sales, 2026-10-24 to 2026-11-16. Range $561.00 to $830.00.$862.00$751.00$640.00$529.002026-10-242026-11-16
Latest recorded sales
1990 Fleer Michael Jordan #26, PSA 10 recorded sales
DateVenueSold for
2026-11-16eBay$635.00
2026-11-16eBay$578.00
2026-11-16eBay$618.00
2026-11-14eBay$625.00
2026-11-13eBay$674.00
Price check: 2026-11-16. A price check does not mean a new sale occurred.Full card details →

The PSA 9 of the same card tells the speed story in miniature. Its comp was $92, built from July sales of $60 to $95. A copy listed at $59.99 on July 27 at 18:12 UTC was gone by 18:40. Twenty eight minutes, on a sixty dollar card. The gap was 35 percent and the buyer did not deliberate.

Real eBay listing photo of a 1990 Fleer Michael Jordan #26 PSA 10 beside the alert numbers: listed at $749.99, sold comp $817, 8 percent below, gone in 11 hours
Receipt: the July 27 Jordan PSA 10. Listed at $749.99 against an $817 comp, gone in 11 hours. The photo is the listing's own.

Vintage Pokemon Moves the Same Way

A 1999 Fossil Zapdos Holo 1st Edition PSA 9 listed at $550 against an $897 comp on September 14 and sold inside a day. A 2002 Expedition Kingler Holo PSA 9 at $497.55 against an $893 comp took five days, which is normal for a card that trades a few times a month instead of a few times a week. The pattern is the same as the sports cards: the bigger the gap on a card people actually want, the shorter the window.

eBay listing page for the 1999 Fossil Zapdos Holo 1st Edition PSA 9 showing the sold banner and the $550 price
eBay's page for the 1st Edition Zapdos PSA 9: sold at $550 on September 14, 19 hours after the alert.

One honest caveat for the vintage Pokemon rows. Sports comps rest on dozens of sales a month; WOTC era holos at a specific grade and printing trade less often, so their comps rest on fewer sales and move more between refreshes. The two cards above cleared quickly, which is the market agreeing with the gap, but on a thinner card treat a 40 percent gap as a prompt to check the sales behind it rather than a verdict. The 30 second routine further down is built for exactly that.

The Listing the Seller Pulled

Twice in five weeks a seller listed a 2003 Topps LeBron James #221 PSA 10 more than a quarter below seven recorded July sales, and twice the seller ended the listing within three days citing an error. The July sales ran $6,999 to $7,999 and the comp was $7,666. The August 22 copy listed at $4,550, 41 percent below, and was ended 40 hours later. The September 22 copy listed at $5,600, 27 percent below, and was ended after 62 hours. Translation: the seller noticed the mistake. The window between a listing going up and the seller noticing is the window a sold-price alert is built to hit, and for 40 hours this one was open.

eBay listing page for the 2003 Topps LeBron James #221 PSA 10 showing the banner This listing was ended by the seller on Sun, Aug 23 at 4:48 PM because there was an error in the listing
eBay's banner on the August 22 listing: ended by the seller because there was an error in the listing. The price shown is the seller's last edit; the alert caught it at $4,550.
2003 Topps LeBron James #221PSA 10
2003 Topps LeBron James #221

Sale-based value

$5,130.00

Price evidence dated 2026-11-15

Verified sales · 58 observations2026-11-15 · $5,040.00
Verified sales, 2026-09-16 to 2026-11-15. Range $4,350.02 to $7,788.00.$8,201.00$6,780.00$5,358.00$3,937.002026-09-162026-11-15
Latest recorded sales
2003 Topps LeBron James #221, PSA 10 recorded sales
DateVenueSold for
2026-11-15Fanatics Collect$5,040.00
2026-11-15Fanatics Collect$5,160.00
2026-11-12Alt$4,716.00
2026-11-09Fanatics Collect$5,160.00
2026-11-09eBay$5,600.00
Price check: 2026-11-16. A price check does not mean a new sale occurred.Full card details →

Worth naming: most of the catches on this page came from sellers with hundreds or thousands of feedback. Mispricing is not a scam signal. It is usually a seller pricing from memory, from a stale guide, or from the wrong grade, and the fix on the seller's side is to end the listing, which is exactly what happened here.

Alert to Gone: How Long the Window Stays Open

Of the eight Buy It Now receipts, five were gone within a day and two within half an hour. The chart puts every receipt on one log scale, from the two minute LeBron to the five day Kingler. Orange bars are under an hour, blue under a day. A saved search digest that arrives at most once per day lands after every orange and blue bar, which is the structural reason a sold-price alert has to check continuously rather than daily.

Historical chart · article published October 15, 2026. Figures are fixed to the original research; see the dated card prices for the latest evidence.

Alert to gone: how long each Buy It Now catch stayed buyableLog scale · scanner timestamp to eBay sold or ended time
2003 Topps Chrome LeBron James #111 PSA 9
21% below
2 minutes
1990 Fleer Michael Jordan #26 PSA 9
35% below
28 minutes
1990 Fleer Michael Jordan #26 PSA 10 (Jul 27)
8% below
11 hours
1990 Fleer Michael Jordan #26 PSA 10 (Jul 25)
10% below
19 hours
1999 Fossil Zapdos Holo 1st Edition PSA 9
39% below
19 hours
2003 Topps LeBron James #221 PSA 10 (pulled)
41% below
40 hours
2003 Topps LeBron James #221 PSA 10 (pulled)
27% below
62 hours
2002 Expedition Kingler Holo PSA 9
44% below
5 days

Orange is under an hour, blue is under a day, grey is longer. The two LeBron #221 bars are listings the seller ended citing an error, so the bar is how long the mistake was buyable. A daily saved-search digest lands after every orange and blue bar on this chart.

Auctions Below Comp Are Not Deals Yet

An auction sitting far below comp with days left is a bid, not a price. The scanner flags auctions too, and the honest finding from four August auction alerts is that every one closed at or near the comp. The Brady Bowman Chrome PSA 9 looked 42 percent below when it was flagged with five days left; it closed at $13,401, above the comp, because July sales had run $12,150 to $15,000 and the market found it. The LeBron Chrome PSA 10, the Mantle, and the Trout all closed within four percent of their comps.

Four auction alerts from August 2026. The bid is what the scanner saw when it flagged the listing; the closing price is a recorded sale. Last column is the close as a share of the comp.
CardAlertBid at alertSold compClosed atClose vs comp
2000 Bowman Chrome Tom Brady #236 PSA 9Aug 2$5,986$10,317$13,401 (Aug 7)130%
2003 Topps Chrome LeBron James #111 PSA 10Aug 4$12,500$16,150$16,400 (Aug 11)102%
1958 Topps Mickey Mantle #150 PSA 4Aug 1$769$1,377$1,400 (Aug 8)102%
2011 Topps Update Mike Trout #US175 PSA 10Aug 15$615$980$937 (Aug 17)96%

Historical chart · article published October 15, 2026. Figures are fixed to the original research; see the dated card prices for the latest evidence.

Auction alerts: bid when flagged, the comp, and the closing priceScanner bid at alert · grade-matched comp · recorded closing sale

Every closing price is a recorded sale. The bid at the alert sat 23 to 44 percent under the comp; the closes landed between 96 and 130 percent of it. The scale is per card, so read each trio on its own.

2000 Bowman Chrome Tom Brady #236PSA 10
2000 Bowman Chrome Tom Brady #236

Sale-based value

$20,650.00

Price evidence dated 2026-11-16

Verified sales · 54 observations2026-11-16 · $18,600.00
Verified sales, 2026-07-06 to 2026-11-16. Range $18,600.00 to $33,250.00.$35,008.00$28,953.00$22,897.00$16,842.002026-07-062026-11-16
Latest recorded sales
2000 Bowman Chrome Tom Brady #236, PSA 10 recorded sales
DateVenueSold for
2026-11-16Fanatics Collect$18,600.00
2026-11-14eBay$23,999.00
2026-11-09Fanatics Collect$19,800.00
2026-11-02eBay$21,500.00
2026-10-31eBay$21,000.00
Price check: 2026-11-16. A price check does not mean a new sale occurred.Find this card →

That is not a failure of the alert. It is what liquid cards do when enough bidders see them. The useful reading of an auction alert is not the gap on the day it fires. It is the reminder to put the card on your list, set a maximum at or under the comp, and bid once in the final minute. Where auction alerts do pay is the quiet close: a bad title, a listing ending at an odd hour, a thin market where the last bidders never show up. Those closes happen every week, and you only catch them if you were already watching with a number in mind.

2011 Topps Update Mike Trout #US175PSA 10
2011 Topps Update Mike Trout #US175

Sale-based value

$895.00

Price evidence dated 2026-11-16

Verified sales · 61 observations2026-11-16 · $843.00
Verified sales, 2026-09-23 to 2026-11-16. Range $100.00 to $1,000.00.$1,108.00$739.00$369.00$0.002026-09-232026-11-16
Latest recorded sales
2011 Topps Update Mike Trout #US175, PSA 10 recorded sales
DateVenueSold for
2026-11-16eBay$843.00
2026-11-16eBay$869.00
2026-11-16eBay$858.88
2026-11-15eBay$809.01
2026-11-15eBay$910.90
Price check: 2026-11-16. A price check does not mean a new sale occurred.Full card details →

The Trout is the cleanest illustration of the close. July PSA 10 sales ran $1,009 to $1,250, the comp was $980, and the scanner flagged the auction on August 15 with bidding at $615. It closed two days later at $937, within five percent of the comp. The Mantle did the same: five PSA 4 sales were on record between July 12 and August 8, from $1,200 to $1,400, the alert fired on August 1 with bidding at $769, and it closed a week later at $1,400. A collector who had set a maximum at the comp and bid in the final minute would have paid market. A collector who chased the gap would have paid more.

Why the Comp Has to Be Grade Matched

The 1990 Fleer Jordan makes the case with one card: the PSA 10 comp was $817 and the PSA 9 comp was $92. A PSA 9 listed at $500 would show as 39 percent below the PSA 10 number and would be more than five times the real price of the card in hand. The LeBron Chrome #111 shows the same thing at the top end, $5,038 for the PSA 9 against $16,150 for the PSA 10. A tool that averages grades together, or pulls a headline price from a guide, cannot tell you anything useful about either listing.

Historical chart · article published October 15, 2026. Figures are fixed to the original research; see the dated card prices for the latest evidence.

Same card, one grade apart: the PSA 9 comp against the PSA 10 compGrade-matched comps from the CardboardSniper pricing engine

A PSA 9 judged against the PSA 10 number would look 50 to 90 percent below market on every card here. The grade is the market, which is why every alert in this article was priced against sales at its own grade.

Every receipt on this page was judged against sales at its own grade from its own grader, and that is the only reason the gap column means anything. A BGS 9.5 is not PSA 10 money. A CGC 9 is not PSA 9 money. Printing matters the same way: 1st Edition, Shadowless, Unlimited, refractors and numbered parallels are separate markets, and a comp built from the scarcer printing applied to the common one is the most common way a deal alert lies to you.

How to Read a Sold-Price Alert in 30 Seconds

The alert has done the hard work. The last thirty seconds are yours. This is the routine that turns an alert into a good buy and keeps you out of the bad ones.

  1. Match the grade and the grader. The comp is only valid for the same grader and grade. A PSA 9 judged against a PSA 10 comp will always look like a bargain.
  2. Match the printing. 1st Edition against 1st Edition, Unlimited against Unlimited, the parallel against the parallel. Check the title and the slab label, not the photo thumbnail.
  3. Look at the sales behind the number. Three sales from this month beat one sale from last winter. If the comp rests on a single sale, or the sales are months apart, treat the gap as a hint, not a fact. Every card page on this site shows the sales so you can look.
  4. Read the listing like a buyer. Front and back photos, a visible cert number, a seller with feedback, returns accepted. If the deal only works because the photos are blurry, pass.
  5. Decide on the gap. Twenty percent or more below a solid comp on a liquid card is a buy now, not a think about it. Eight to fifteen percent is a collector discount. Sixty percent below on a trophy card is a research prompt, because it is usually a reprint, a cracked slab, or a scam.

When the comp is wrong. Every sold-price tool, this one included, is only as good as the sales it matched. The failure to watch for is a comp built from a scarcer printing or a higher grade than the listing in front of you. A listing that sits for weeks at the alert price is telling you the same thing. Verify the printing and the grade before you click buy, every time.

What 77 Days of Sold-Price Alerts Look Like

Between July 21 and October 8, 2026 the scanner flagged 8,783 distinct listings priced 8 to 60 percent below their comp; 2,642 of those were priced against a full grade-matched comp with recorded sales behind it, and every chart below uses only that set. The rest were priced from an estimate, which the alert says plainly, and are excluded here. Two thirds of the full-comp catches were Buy It Now and one third were auctions. The median gap was 34 percent and the median listing price was $499.

Full-comp catches
2,642
of 8,783 flagged, Jul 21 to Oct 8
Buy It Now share
67%
1,773 Buy It Now, 869 auctions
25%+ below comp
1,800
68% of full-comp catches
Over $1,000
935
310 of them over $5,000

Historical chart · article published October 15, 2026. Figures are fixed to the original research; see the dated card prices for the latest evidence.

How far below the comp: 2,642 scanner catches by gapCardboardSniper scanner · Jul 21 to Oct 8, 2026 · full grade-matched comps only

Each bar is the number of distinct listings flagged in that band. Auctions skew to the biggest gaps because an early bid is far below where the auction will close; the Buy It Now bars are the ones where the gap is a real price.

Historical chart · article published October 15, 2026. Figures are fixed to the original research; see the dated card prices for the latest evidence.

What the catches cost: listing price of 2,642 scanner catchesCardboardSniper scanner · Jul 21 to Oct 8, 2026

Mispricing is not a cheap-card phenomenon. 935 of the 2,642 catches carried a listing price above $1,000, and 310 were above $5,000.

Historical chart · article published October 15, 2026. Figures are fixed to the original research; see the dated card prices for the latest evidence.

Catches per week, Buy It Now and auctionCardboardSniper scanner · weeks starting Sunday · full comps only

The jump in the week of August 9 is the scanner's watch list growing from a few dozen cards to the full house list. The later weeks are the steady state: roughly 150 to 300 verified below-comp listings a week.

The spread matters more than the count. Catches did not cluster in cheap cards or in one hobby: vintage basketball, modern baseball rookies, WOTC era Pokemon and raw singles all produced below-comp listings in the same weeks. A saved search watches one query. A scanner that prices everything against sold data watches the whole board, which is why the receipts above range from a sixty dollar Jordan to a five figure Brady.

Set Up the Alert That Would Have Caught These

Each catch above came from an alert that named a specific card and grade. Not a player, not a set, the card. The tighter the alert, the cleaner the comp, and the faster you can act when it fires.

  • Name the exact card, grader and grade: 2003 Topps Chrome LeBron James #111 PSA 9, not LeBron rookie.
  • Set the deal threshold at 20 percent below comp for cards you want to flip, 10 percent for cards you want to own.
  • Turn on instant email. A daily digest would have missed every Buy It Now catch on this page.
  • Add auctions only for cards you are prepared to watch to the close, with a maximum bid already decided.
  • When the alert fires, run the 30 second check and buy or pass. Do not reopen the research.

CardboardSniper watches eBay and Fanatics Collect around the clock, prices every new listing against grade-matched sold comps, and emails you within minutes when a card lists below market. Pick a plan and put the card you are hunting on the scanner tonight. The sports card alerts and Pokemon card alerts pages walk through the setup for each hobby.

Sold-Price Deal Alert FAQ

What is a trading card deal alert based on sold prices?

An alert that compares a new listing to recorded sales of the same card at the same grade, instead of to a price you typed in or to a keyword match. The alert shows the listing price, the sold comp and the gap, so you can judge the deal without opening the sold listings yourself.

How is the sold comp calculated?

CardboardSniper averages the last three sane recorded sales of the exact card, grader and grade, after trimming obvious outliers. A PSA 9 is never priced against PSA 10 sales. If a grade has no recent sales, the alert shows no verdict rather than borrowing a number from another grade.

Are the snipes on this page real?

Yes. Every row is a real listing the scanner flagged, shown with the price it listed at and the comp it was judged against. Each one was re-checked on eBay in October 2026 and against the recorded sales behind the comp; the eBay banners in the screenshots are the proof. Closing prices for the auctions are recorded sales.

How fast do underpriced Buy It Now listings sell?

Fast. In this set a LeBron Chrome PSA 9 listed 21 percent below comp sold in two minutes, a 1990 Fleer Jordan PSA 9 was gone in 28 minutes, and two Jordan PSA 10s listed under 10 percent below comp were gone within a day. eBay saved search emails arrive at most once per day, which is after the window closes.

Do sold-price deal alerts work for auctions?

They flag auctions, but an auction below comp with days left is a bid, not a price. The four auction alerts on this page closed at 96 to 130 percent of the comp. Use the alert to put the card on your list and set a maximum bid, and treat quiet closes on thin markets or bad titles as the real opportunity.

What if the comp is wrong?

It happens, usually when sales from a scarcer printing or a higher grade get matched to the listing. Check that the grader, grade and printing match before you buy, and look at how many sales sit behind the number. A listing that stays unsold for weeks at the alert price is a sign the comp is stale.

Is buying an underpriced listing fast considered sniping, and is it allowed?

Buying a mispriced Buy It Now listing quickly is simply buying, and last second auction bidding is allowed on eBay, including software that places bids for you. Neither is a loophole. The only edge is seeing the listing first and knowing the comp cold. The full policy question is covered in is eBay sniping allowed.


Put the receipts to work: the comp method explains the number inside every alert, the free card value checker shows the grade-matched comp for any slab, and the live alert feed is where the next one of these surfaces.